Breaking AP News

Loading...

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Here is an idea to help the economy that won't cost the government a dime.....

Here at NWR, we spend a lot of time bashing the deep thoughts that the Democrats come up with to help the economy. For the most part, their ideas include raising taxes on some group of disfavored individuals - smokers, the wealthy, beer and wine drinkers.

We spend a lot of time shooting at the "fish in a barrel", I thought perhaps we at NWR should offer ideas to the Democrats that may actually accomplish something.

Let me make a suggestion to the Democrats in Congress that would help the economy, put money in people's pockets, and won't cost the government a dime.

There are a large group of individuals (of which I am one) who have a large amount of debt from their college educations. In some cases, that debt can equal or perhaps exceed the cost of a typical mortgage.

Generally speaking, those of us with this type of debt are well-educated, middle-class (perhaps upper middle class) individuals who are just trying to make ends meet. Why do I say that? Because wealthy people don't have to take out loans to go to school, and low income folks get help in the form of grants and scholarships. Those of us in the middle are forced to take out student loans.

I am by no means complaining, let me make that clear, about my loans.

When you finish your education, you have the opportunity to "consolidate" your student loans into one loan so you have one monthly payment, instead of several payments to several different lenders. I consolidated my loans as soon as I was out of school. By consolidating those loans, I locked myself into an interest rate for the life of the loans. At the time, for many of us, the rate wasn't half bad. Today, the rate is more than half bad.

The problem is that student loan borrowers can only consolidate their loans one time. There is no "reconsolidation" or "refinancing" allowed of student loans. Borrowers are not even given the opportunity to shop around to see if there is a lower rate available. It is a federal law that prevents this from happening.

If the feds changed the law, consider what would happen. First, it would allow these middle to upper-middle income earners the opportunity to refinance their loans and hopefully lower their monthly payments. This would indeed provide almost immediate relief to these income earners.

Making this change would, by definition, put more money in the pockets of these folks much the same way a tax cut does. The theory behind cutting taxes (and having people spend that money in the economy) necessarily would apply here - putting more money in people's pockets means more money into the economy.

It wouldn't cost the government a dime. Why? Because although many of these loans are guaranteed by the government, and a GSE (Sallie Mae) administers many loans, in the end the GSE is self-supporting, and does not rely upon federal dollars. All it would require is a change in the law.

Why would the lenders agree to this change? After all, by allowing borrowers to shop around for lower interest rates, doesn't that mean that lenders wouldn't be making as much money as they can make now? Yes.

But student loan lenders (like Sallie Mae and others) would be wise to learn from the Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac debacle. If student loan borrowers are suddenly unable to pay their loans, Sallie Mae might crumble alongside the rubble of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Allowing student loan borrowers to refinance their loans so the borrowers can continue to make their monthly payments would mean less defaults for the lenders, and greater long-term stability for those lenders, as well.

Also, a recent decision by the 9th Circuit has created a way for student borrowers to avoid student debt through the bankruptcy courts. If the law doesn't change soon, don't be surprised if Student Lenders find themselves standing in line in the bankruptcy courts trying to recover whatever they can from student loan borrowers. Changing the law may have minimal short-term impacts, but will likely produce long-term benefits for student lenders and may be just what the doctor ordered in this economy.

The Congress and the Bush administration has been reluctant to change the student lending laws for some time now, and I do not understand why. But the Democrat Congress and President Bush, as they struggle to find ways to relieve economic pressures on Americans, would be wise to consider changing the laws governing student loans.

Although ultimately the change, in the grand scheme of things, may not have a substantial impact on the economy, every little bit helps. And if making this change will have only positive effects, without costing the taxpayers a dime, then why not do it?

10 comments:

poor boomer said...

Why would Sallie Mae crumble when student loans are not dischargable in bankruptcy and are readily collectible from anyone with a job or Social Security check, and an income?

My monthly income is $900 and I have a student loan garnishment of $135. I'm living on fumes but Sallie Mae isn't losing any money because of me.

Anonymous said...

There isn't anything that "costs the government a dime." The government doesn't have any money to lose, other than what taxpayers earn first and then give the government. We should try and remember this during the coming discussions over budget deficits.

verasoie said...

Wow Coyote,

A genuinely productive and non-"concern trollish" suggestion from you for the Democrats and Government in general, and not a bad one at that... I'm impressed.

Non Oblitus said...

My favorite idea is to finally abolish the use of the dollar bill thru an act of Congress and mandate the dollar coin.

Ultimately, the only people that would be effected negatively are strippers.

Tho, on the upside, it could also make it fun. Set a stack of a dollar coins on the rail and tell her "you can keep all the coins you can pick up, without using your hands."

On a related note, DO NOT try to slide your credit card between her butt cheeks while screaming "Charge it, baby!" The bouncers will bounce you rather quickly.

Anonymous said...

Along these lines, we should be able to write off student loan payments (at least the interest) on our taxes.

Student loan debt can easily reach the size of a mortgage and is non-dischargeable in bankruptcy. At the very least you should be able to write it off against your income.

Anonymous said...

Good Idea. You should ask Walden to introduce it since I assume you do not have any democratic friends. When he does, it won't pass but the idea will be stolen by a Democrat so they can get the credit.

Satria Sudeki said...

It is happy to see your posting. Yes really informative article. I will tell this information again to my friend, oh yes I suggest you to check my blog on www.top-studentloans.blogspot.com , I hope the article on my blog will be usefull for you… and we can share each other. thank you… ;-)

I am Coyote said...

Verasoie,
You must be wrong. Because Dave Lister said you will never see ideas discussed in the blogosphere and only carping about my side and your side.

LOL

Dare!PDX said...

Funny story about student loans.

When taking bankruptcy in lawschool the semester progressed through the Federal bankruptcy code. When we came to the subject of student loans the professor went on a purposeful tangent.

At one point he showed that for those of us with large student loans if we ever entered bankruptcy we wouldn't be able to discharge most types of student loans. He mentioned that there were many tax benefits to consolidating your student loan into your home loan if possible.

First benefit.... Tax deductible interest regardless of what type of student loan debt consolidated which put our home equity to work where our student loans weren't as beneficial.

Second benefit... If ever you entered bankruptcy the debt owed beyond the market value of your home would be discharged.

At that point the professor just paused (uncharacteristic for his instruction style).

At once the class all exhaled with an audible hmmmmmmmmmm. Then the class realized what every student thought at the same time and started laughing.

Needless to say. Coyote, consolidate into your real estate if you can get a better interest rate.

Anonymous said...
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.

Custom Links Bookmarks

Digg

Infocious RSS raw feed - channel BNAPPOLITICS